Chapter 3. Theoretical Approaches Toward The Study of Religion

3.1 What is religion?

  • Religion often engages with a God/Gods/supernatural beings
  • Religion often defines morality
  • Religion includes community and ritual
  • Religion controls people’s behavior
  • While most religions believe in a God, not all religions do. For example: there are some branches of Buddhism that focus exclusively on the human experience, inward reflection, and the psyche instead of focusing on whether a god exists or not.
  • Religion very often defines morality, but this is not a unique characteristic of religion. For example, our political parties also strive to define morality for the entire nation and, typically, these definitions are not religious.
  • Most religions do build community through ritual practice, but we similarly have countless cultural rituals that are non-religious (for example: gift-giving during birthdays). So, this is not a unique definition of religion.
  • And, like all elements of culture, religion controls our behavior by promising salvation, enlightenment, or good fortune in exchange for “good” acts. But, as you likely already understand, our behaviors are controlled by non-religious forces, too including: the law, family structures, employment/capitalism, gender roles, and more.

3.2 Edward Burnett Tylor

3.3 Why Magic Works

  1. Randomly, the desired results will occur. Causing the believers to think that the magic practiced worked.
  2. Sometimes, the person performing the magic will use deception to convince participants.
  3. People tend to remember positive outcomes more often than the occasions when magic doesn’t work.
  4. When magic doesn’t produce the desired results, believers will blame counter-magic from someone else (Winnick 334).
  • The human mind frequently sees coincidence as evidence of causation. We might assume that two, unrelated events are causing one another (even in cases where the two events are not related).
  • Magic often attempts to cause outcomes that happen naturally. For example, people are unlikely to perform a rain ritual outside of the rainy season. So, when the rain ritual is performed immediately before the rains naturally start, a community might associate the magic with the outcome.
  • As humans, we are very resistant to changing our beliefs! Overcoming the long-held belief that magic exists can be very hard to overcome.
  • Practitioners of magic typically do not ask impossible things of magic. Magical beliefs and practices are usually restrained to the realm of possibility.

3.4 Cultural Evolutionism, Animism, and Diffusionism

  • Cultural Evolutionism: The idea that cultures change and adapt over time to meet people’s changing needs (Winick 196).
  • Animism: The belief in spirits beings (Winick 26; Durkheim 27).

3.5 Critiquing Tylor

  1. Tylor’s “cultural evolutionism” purported that human cultures inevitably change and evolve over time. We know that it is true that cultures evolve over time, but Tylor’s hypothesis specifically argued that cultures (and religions) evolved in a linear manner. In other words, Tylor was of the view that all religions would evolve from spirit worship, to polytheism, to monotheism (this was, obviously, because he believed in a monotheistic religion and felt that his religion was the most advanced/superior). As we know, religions and cultures do not evolve in any kind of predetermined, linear manner. Furthermore, there is no such thing as a “more” or “less” evolved culture (these are all culturally-specific ideas). So, we do still consider Tylor’s ideas because cultures do evolve and adapt in a variety of directions, but we do not embrace the idea that cultures evolve in a linear manner (Reed 322–323).
  2. Tylor established the idea of “animism” or the idea that all religions share one thing in common: the belief in spirits (Stocking 103). For Tylor, spirits might manifest as human souls, as the power of the Gods/divine, or as the spirits of nature. While this is an interesting argument, we know that some forms of Buddhism do not actually believe in any spirit beings at all (not even the human soul). Furthermore, some people believe in supernatural spirit beings such as the existence of leprechauns, ghosts, or guardian angels but they may not belong to an organized religion that governs these beliefs. So, while the term “animism” is helpful to discuss a common thread across religions, it’s not a universal or exclusive characteristic that can be applied in all cases.

3.7 Robert Marrett and Animatism

3.8 Marxism

3.9 “The Opium of the People”

3.10 Clifford Geertz and Symbolism

  1. “A system of symbols which acts to
  2. Establish powerful, pervasive, and long-lasting moods and motivation in [people] by
  3. Formulating conceptions of a general order of existence and by
  4. Clothing these conceptions with such an aura of factuality that
  5. The moods and motivations seem uniquely realistic. “(97)
  1. Religion is a system of symbols. When we look at our own religions, we can see a variety of symbols that are quite literal and then other symbols which are more powerful and which reflect our ideologies. Consider, for example, when you enter a church you may see a crucifix on the wall. The crucifix represents Christ’s death (this is a literal symbol). However, Jesus’ crucifixion symbolizes a much more important set of values that are central to Christianity including: God’s unending love for humanity and Jesus’ immense suffering to gain humanity’s forgiveness.
  2. These symbols (both large and small) establish certain moods and motivations within us. For example, at the most literal level, you may not feel particularly religious until you enter a beautiful church. Upon seeing the tall structure, stained glass windows with religious symbols on them, and upon hearing the religious hymns, you may start to feel more religious and to reflect on religious concepts. On an ideological level, the symbols of your religion establish motivations in you that change your behavior. To use Christianity example again, you may decide to forgive someone who wronged you based on your understanding that Jesus suffered a great deal and still forgave humanity.
  3. Using symbols, religions establish a general order of existence. For example, nearly all religions promise good outcomes for humans who behave properly. Perhaps your religion promises Heaven, blessings for future generations, or reincarnation into a better life. However the universe is ordered in the context of your own religion, these concepts are presented using religious symbols. For example: artwork and religious texts may reflect the wheel of reincarnation or a soul’s ascent into heaven.
  4. Geertz points out that these symbols and correlating value systems are presented to us as absolute fact. As we’ve discussed before, religion requires faith to exist and it cannot be proven scientifically. As the majority of humanity is assigned a religion immediately at birth, the ideologies of our religions are established as absolute fact in our minds.
  5. Then, because these religious values and principles are established as fact and presented symbolically, the moods and motivations feel like they are uniquely our own and they feel like they are coming, organically and naturally, from our spirits.

3.11 Functionalists on Religion

3.12 Émile Durkheim on Functionalism

  • Religion lays out basic rules for behavior, creates a uniform understanding of which behaviors are appropriate and which are not
  • Religion restrains natural selfishness and promotes cooperation (Stein and Stein 18–20).

3.13 Common Characteristics of Religion

  • Animism: Belief in spirit beings (as discussed above).
  • Enchanted Worldview: Belief in powers or worlds that are not perceived by humans. An “enchanted worldview” is the idea that there is a great deal in the universe that human beings can not fully see; some examples include the existence of ghosts, guardian angels, a karmic law, the presence of magic, and so on. Most religions (not all) embrace an idea that there are elements of reality that are beyond our perception.
  • Ritual: Ceremonial actions that are performed according to a prescribed order.
  • Death Ritual: Funerary practices intended to mark the passing of a person. Death rituals are usually to be the final rite of passage and vary widely across the globe.
  • Magic: Whenever people try to take control of their circumstances by calling upon supernatural powers, anthropologists consider them to be engaging with magic. For example: if you complete a spell in the woods to bring about fertility then you are engaging in magic. At the same time, if you are praying to the Christian God to give you an A on an exam, then you are engaging in magic (in an anthropological sense).
  • Myth: A sacred story that informs a people’s worldview.
  • Meaning: Attempts to create order and control of the natural world in the face of uncertainty. This is arguably the most important element of religion: religions help human beings create a sense of meaning in their lives by creating community, developing a sense of morality, and by answering the questions that are, otherwise, unanswerable.

3.14 Taboos

3.15 “Baseball Magic”

Bibliography

About

--

--

--

Cultural Anthropologist in Los Angeles

Love podcasts or audiobooks? Learn on the go with our new app.

Recommended from Medium

We are the Adults in the Room

Meditation & Mental Health

Got Doubts?

A Christian perspective on abortion

The Perils of Wrong Prayers versus The Power of Praying.

The Incidental Glimpses Of Life

woman standing in water during daytime

An Enlightened Tree

Conversion

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store
Amanda Zunner-Keating

Amanda Zunner-Keating

Cultural Anthropologist in Los Angeles

More from Medium

Jungian influence on ‘Demian’ by Hermann Hesse

Demian by Hermann Hesse

Searching for A Creative Diavolo

A “New-Style” NFL Gameplay Analysis

Why Newspaper Paywalls Contribute To The Fake News Pandemic?